|
1. Have you ever needed to write a C.V. or letter like those on these web pages?
Of 23 responses 17 reported that they had previously needed to write similar C.V.’s or letters. However, it was unclear whether these had been in Spanish or English. It would be helpful for a future project to add the target language to any question aimed at understanding previous student experience of similar material. Some students did specify that they had only completed such tasks in English.
2. If you answered yes to the previous question, what resources did you use?
The use of other people’s C.V.’s as a model, information from school careers’ offices and careers’ classes, text books, enlisting the help of Spanish friends, and consultation the model letters and C.V.’s found in dictionaries were responses to this question. Some of the latter again indicated that previous experience for some students had been in English alone. One student, however, reported writing a letter similar to one of the samples to her bank in Minorca!
It was interesting to note that there were some students who had previously consulted computer resources. Although only one of these appeared to be Internet based, replies were not always sufficiently clear. One student had used "resources on school computers" and a template C.V., while another reported the use of previous examples on databases.
3. Were these pages adequate for you to complete the task, or did you need to consult other resources as well?
17 of the 23 students simply answered yes to this question but others added further comments. 4 of the latter felt that the layout was adequate but had also needed to consult a dictionary for specialised vocabulary. This was particularly true for the C.V in order to name jobs which they had done or subjects that they had studied. A future improvement may be to add an introduction to the web pages with advice on opening several windows and accessing online dictionaries.
4. Were you able to complete task in the time available?
16 students of 23 had been able to complete the tasks in class time.
5. Did you find these pages well laid-out and easy to read?
Students were asked to grade the layout and convenience of the pages (see Appendix A). 5 represents excellent, the number of students indicating each response is given below the figure.
6. If or when you study abroad, would you consider using this resource via the Internet?
All 23 students replied affirmatively. 4 added "definitely".
7. What situations not covered by the pages do you feel it would have been helpful to include in future?
While some students felt that the situations they would be likely to need were covered, two improvements were suggested:
All situations were included but additional information relevant to each topic would be helpful.
A contents page would aid navigation.
A variety of possible additions were also put forward:
A list of newspapers or magazines carrying job vacancies.
A reply to a job offer.
A letter of thanks.
An application for work experience.
A cover note to explain an enclosure.
Inclusion of information on working in Spain.
Further application letters containing more detail.
A section on the model C.V. covering gap year experience.
A letter in case of personal injury in a car accident.
A letter to arrange a business meeting.
8. Any other comments or suggestions.
While most students chose not to use this space, 2 commented on typing errors that they had spotted, which will be amended. The majority of those who did respond commented favourably on the pages:
"Really good, useful resource",
"I think it’s a brilliant system and very easy to use"
"Excellent idea"
"Very helpful"
"A very useful system"
"Good idea"
"It was very well set out and easy to use and will be very helpful for future reference".
|